Crystal Radio Sets and Op Amps—Both Can Detect RF Signals


How are unwanted noise and dc offsets getting into my precision amplifier circuit?

RAQ:  Issue 94


On each birthday when I was young, my dad would take me to the toy store to pick out my present. He always vetted the toy, saying something like, “Now really, what are you going to do with that?” Or, “How long do you think that will last?” I sometimes think that he wanted to make sure that he would enjoy my choice as well. His questions forced me, even at an early age, to think critically about the decisions and choices I was making.

Some of my favorite childhood toys were: an erector set and a Radio Shack 101 project electronics kit, but my earliest kit, the one that sparked my interest in electronics, was a crystal radio set. I tuned in AM radio stations and magically plucked them from the airwaves… with no batteries or power supply! How cool was that? How did it work? Some 40+ years later, who would think that I would tie that crystal radio set into an op amp RAQ? Actually, it wasn’t hard.

A crystal radio uses a PN junction to rectify an RF signal envelope to produce a detected voltage. Did you know that some op amps can do the same thing? All op amps feature some variation of a differential pair front end. Depending on the current flowing in the diff pair, and the unwanted RF signal frequency and strength, the diff pair can actually act as a high-frequency detector. That’s great if want to listen to an AM radio station, but not good if that signal inadvertently enters your precision amplifier circuit. In many precision applications, the signals are very small voltages. When these unwanted signals are detected in the op amp, they produce a wide spectrum of signals and harmonics—as well as dc voltages. These dc components can shift bias levels and introduce system errors.

So what can you do? A variety of shielding, filtering, and layout techniques exist, but all add complexity to the circuit. Perhaps the best solution is to use one of ADI’s new precision op amps with built-in EMI filtering capability. The AD8657, AD8659, AD8546, AD8548 and soon to be released ADA4661-2 precision op amps all feature built in EMI filtering. This added technology greatly simplifies the designer’s job, reduces complexity, shrinks board area, and lowers cost.

When you want to listen to an AM radio station, get a crystal radio; when you’re looking for peace and quiet, choose a precision amp with built in EMI filtering. You’ll be glad that you did.

I invite you to comment on Crystal Radios and Op Amps in the Analog Dialogue Community on EngineerZone.

James Wong, Joe Buxton, Adolfo Garcia, James Bryant, "Filtering and Protection Against EMI/RFI" and "Input Stage RFI Rectification Sensitivity", Chapter 1 (pdf), pg. 21-55 of Systems Application Guide (zip), 1993, Analog Devices, Inc., Norwood, MA, ISBN 0-916550-13-3.

Walt Kester, Walt Jung, Chuck Kitchen, "Preventing RFI Rectification", Chapter 10 (pdf), pg 10.39-10.43 of Practical Design Techniques for Sensor Signal Conditioning (zip), Analog Devices, Inc., Norwood, MA, 1999, ISBN 0-916550-20-6. (pdf)


John Ardizzoni

John Ardizzoni

John started at Analog Devices in 2002, as an Application Engineer in the High Speed Amplifier group. Prior to joining Analog Devices John worked for IBM, in RFIC applications and at M/A-COM for 20 years. John is also co-author of Analog Devices Rarely Asked Questions (RAQ's) column. John has over 30 years experience in the electronics industry, and has authored numerous articles and design ideas.