Analog Dialogue: A forum for the exchange of circuits, systems, and software for real-world signal processing.
Home     Analog Devices     Feedback     Subscribe     Archives     简体中文     日本語
Advanced Search

Rarely Asked Questions – Issue 83, July 2012

Dual Op Amps and Double Agents: They may not always appear to be who they say they are…

dual amps and double agents

Q: Are dual op amps just duplicates of the single version of the op amp? Do they offer the same performance?

A: That’s a great question. Actually, there’s quite a bit to it, from the perspectives of both the user and the silicon designer. Multiple op amps (duals, triples, quads, and even the occasional octal) are very popular with customers who use many op amps in their circuits, and for good reason. Multiple op amps offer the advantages of less board area, reduced cost, and better matching. As for electrical performance, this cuts both ways, and we’ll talk about it in a minute.

In many cases, multiple op amps are a very close approximation to the single. As you can imagine, there must be some redundancy the silicon designer can take advantage of with two duplicate parts, right? Yes, you’re right; one example of this is the op amp’s bias circuitry. Instead of duplicating the bias circuit for each op amp, it is often modified to accommodate all amplifiers, reducing complexity, die area, and cost. Reduced die area has a direct impact on the size and cost of the packaged op amps; it also lowers board cost (smaller board), assembly cost (one insertion), and inventory cost (one part vs. many). The amplifiers share a common piece of silicon, so they track extremely well, providing another advantage.

There are a few things to watch out for, however. Multiple op amps dissipate more power per package. Since the supply current is multiplied by the number of op amps, the power dissipation will increase; this can result in higher junction temperatures. As alluded to, multiples present challenges to the silicon designer as well. One of the issues with multiples is the layout. Compromises must be made, which can result in degradation in some electrical performance. Optimized for flow, size, and performance, the die layout can affect parameters such as offset voltage and drift. Also, due to tighter quarters, crosstalk can become an issue, especially at high frequencies. A few of ADI’s high-speed amplifiers and differential amplifiers are offered with two separate die in a single package, however, providing excellent crosstalk performance and additional design freedom.

In summary, multiple op amps are a great choice when a circuit calls for several op amps, and for good reason: lower costs, smaller PCB area, easier inventory management, and better electrical performance.

For More Information

Analog Dialogue:
Simple Op Amp Measurements (pdf)

Product Pages:
ADA4940-1 / ADA4940-2: Ultralow Power, Low Distortion ADC Driver
ADA4896-2: 1 nV/√Hz, Low Power, Rail-to-Rail Output Amplifiers
ADA4897-1 / ADA4897-2: 1 nV/√Hz, Low Power, Rail-to-Rail Output Amplifiers
ADA4857-1 / ADA4857-2: Ultralow Distortion, Low Power, Low Noise, High Speed Op Amp

Technical Articles:
Op amps: to dual or not to dual? (Part 1 of 2)
Op amps: to dual or not to dual? (Part 2 of 2)

Technical Documentation:
Operational Amplifiers Selection Guide (pdf)
Op Amp Application Handbook

Author
john_ardizzoni  John Ardizzoni [john.ardizzoni@analog.com] is a technical product manager in the High Speed Linear group. John joined Analog Devices in 2002, received his BSEE from Merrimack College in North Andover, Massachusetts, and has over 30 years experience in the electronics industry.

 Have a question involving a perplexing or unusual analog problem?

Submit your question to: www.analog.com/askjohn

 

Copyright 1995- Analog Devices, Inc. All rights reserved.